How to Best Handle Conflicts of Interest in Research | Orvium

Open Science Jul 7, 2023 Ver este post en Español

In the research world, conflict of interest (COI) is always a risk, and this usually occurs when a researcher has competing interests that may interfere with their research. These interests could be financial, personal, or institutional and could lead to bias, mistrust, and a lack of transparency in research findings.

In this article, we will define conflict of interest in research, give examples of COI, explore how it affects research, and discuss potential solutions to minimize its impact.

What is Conflict of Interest in Research?

Conflict of research interest refers to a situation where a researcher has external interests that may influence their research findings’ objectivity, integrity, and credibility. COI can arise when a researcher has financial, personal, or institutional relationships that could affect their research, such as:

Financial conflicts of interest: when a researcher has economic interests in the outcome of their study, such as ownership of a company or stock in a pharmaceutical company that develops drugs.
Personal conflicts of interest: when a researcher has personal relationships that could affect their research, such as close friendships or family ties with participants or co-authors.
Institutional conflicts of interest: when a researcher’s institution has financial or other interests in the research outcome, such as a university that receives funding from a pharmaceutical company.

Examples of Conflict of Interest in Research

Conflict of interest can take many forms and is not always easy to detect. Here are some examples of COI in research:

a researcher that is employed by a company that produces a product they are researching;
a researcher who serves on the advisory board of a pharmaceutical company that produces a drug that they are researching;
a researcher who receives funding from a government agency has a vested interest in the outcome of their research;
a researcher with a financial interest in publishing their research, such as receiving royalties from a book or article;
a researcher with a personal relationship with a participant in their study could compromise the objectivity of their research, such as a romantic partner or close friend.

How Conflict of Interest Affects Research

Conflict of interest can affect research in several ways:

Bias: COI can lead to bias in research findings, as the researcher may consciously or unconsciously skew the results in favor of their interests or those who fund or employ them.
Credibility: conflict of interest can also damage the credibility of the research and the researcher. When a conflict of interest is discovered, it can cast doubt on the study’s validity and the researcher’s motives.
Ethics: COI can raise ethical concerns about the treatment of research participants. For example, a researcher with a financial interest in a particular outcome may be tempted to manipulate data or withhold information from participants to achieve that outcome.
Public perception: last but not least, conflict of interest can also have a negative impact on public perception of research and science as a whole. When the public becomes aware of conflicts of interest, it can erode trust in the scientific community and lead to skepticism about the legitimacy of research findings.

Researchers need to be aware of these potential impacts and take steps to minimize the risks associated with conflict of interest. This can include being transparent about potential conflicts, involving independent reviewers or advisors, and establishing clear guidelines for ethical conduct in research.

Solutions to Conflict of Interest in Research

To minimize the impact of conflict of research interest, there are several potential solutions:

Disclosure: researchers should disclose any potential conflicts of interest at the outset of their research. This can help mitigate the conflict’s impact by making others aware of the potential bias and allowing for independent review and oversight.
Separation of roles: in cases where a researcher has a potential conflict of interest, it may be necessary to separate their roles. For example, a researcher employed by a company that produces a product they are researching may need to hand off specific responsibilities to another researcher who does not have a conflict of interest.
Independent oversight: establishing independent oversight or research review can help identify and mitigate potential conflicts of interest. This can include separate ethics review boards, external peer reviewers, or independent statisticians to analyze the data.
Funding transparency: funding sources should be publicly disclosed and available. This can help to identify potential conflicts of interest and allow for independent review of the research findings.
Collaboration: collaboration between researchers and stakeholders with diverse perspectives can help to identify and address potential conflicts of interest. This can include involving patient groups, community organizations, or independent experts in the research process.

These are just a few examples of potential solutions to address conflict of research interest. Ultimately, it is up to individual researchers, institutions, and funding agencies to implement policies and procedures that effectively manage and mitigate the risks associated with conflict of interest.

Conclusion

Conflict of research interest is a complex issue that can affect research findings’ objectivity, integrity, and credibility. Researchers, institutions, and peer reviewers should work together to minimize the impact of COI on research by disclosing external interests, subjecting research to rigorous peer review, separating roles, and establishing oversight mechanisms. By doing so, we can ensure that research remains trustworthy and credible.

Thanks to blockchain technology, our platform can offer several potential benefits in addressing conflict of research interest:

Transparency: our platform allows for transparent tracking of the entire research process, from the data collection phase to publication. This can help to identify potential conflicts of interest and increase the credibility and transparency of research findings.
Immutable records: by using blockchain technology, Orvium can ensure that records of the research process are tamper-proof and cannot be altered or manipulated. This can help increase trust in scientific publishing and reduce the risk of conflicts of interest.
Decentralization: our decentralized platform allows for a more democratic and inclusive approach to scientific publishing, reducing the influence of specific stakeholders or funding sources that may have a conflict of interest. This can help to ensure that financial or other interests do not unduly influence research findings.
Incentives: lastly, we offer a reward system for peer reviewers and authors, which can incentivize ethical behavior and reduce the risk of conflicts of interest. By offering rewards for high-quality research and peer review, we promote transparency and objectivity in the scientific publishing process.

While our platform cannot eliminate conflicts of research interest entirely, its blockchain-based platform offers several potential solutions to address them and improve the transparency and credibility of the scientific publishing process.

If you want to learn more about our platform, make sure to visit our website and platform. And also, make sure to follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin, or Instagram to keep up with the latest news and product features.